Championships and accomplishments
Cole is a record setting three-time ROH World Champion
Combat Zone Wrestling
CZW World Junior Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
Best of the Best X (2011)
Dreams Fighting Entertainment/World Wrestling League
DFE Openweight Championship/WWL Heavyweight Championship[Note 1] (1 time)
Eastern Wrestling Alliance
EWA Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)
Ground Breaking Wrestling
Battle of Gettysburg (2009)
International Wrestling Cartel
IWC Super Indy Championship (1 time)
Super Indy 16 (2017)
Maryland Championship Wrestling
MCW Rage Television Championship (2 times)]
Shane Shamrock Memorial Cup (2012)
New Horizon Pro Wrestling
NHPW Art of Fighting Championship (1 time)
Premiere Wrestling Xperience
PWX Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
Preston City Wrestling
PCW Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)
Pro Wrestling Guerrilla
PWG World Championship (1 time)
Battle of Los Angeles (2012)
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
Ranked No. 9 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2014
Pro Wrestling World-1
World-1 North American Championship (1 time)
Shinya Hashimoto Memorial Cup (2010)
Real Championship Wrestling
RCW Cruiserweight Championship (1 time)
RCW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Devon Moore
Ring of Honor
ROH World Championship (3 times)
ROH World Television Championship (1 time)
ROH World Championship Tournament (2013)
ROH World Tag Team Championship No. 1 Contender Lottery Tournament (2011) – with Kyle O’Reilly
Survival of the Fittest (2014)
SoCal Uncensored
Match of the Year (2012) with Kyle O’Reilly vs. Super Smash Bros. (Player Uno and Stupefied) and The Young Bucks on July 21
Match of the Year (2016) with The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson) vs. Matt Sydal, Ricochet and Will Ospreay on September 3
Wrestler of the Year (2013)
WrestleCircus
Big Top Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Britt Baker
Wrestling Observer Newsletter
5 Star Match (2016) with The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson) vs. Matt Sydal, Ricochet and Will Ospreay on September 3[183]
Rookie of the Year (2010)
WXW C4